"This Is What It Looked Like" stands out in the supernatural horror genre by featuring a deaf boy, Timothy, whose imaginative world and connection to his puppets intertwine with the eerie occurrences in their new home. The story delves deeply into family dynamics, especially the strained relationship between Helen and Frank, which adds a layer of psychological drama. The film also presents a unique angle by beginning with Tina, a real estate agent desperate to sell the haunted house, adding socio-economic themes. The rich historical backstory involving witchcraft and mysterious disappearances builds suspense, culminating in a climactic confrontation that blends physical and psychological horror, leading to a suspenseful and emotional resolution.